LooriaLooria
Open menu

Cake Pan Comparison

11 results
Reset
award-badge

Best for Most

in Cake Pan

USA Pan Aluminized Steel 9x2 Inch Round Layer Cake Pan
A

46 reviews

$21
·
Amazon
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking
•
Nonstick and easy to clean
•
Happy with the build quality
•
Rusts after one use if not cleaned properly
•
Waiting until after a good amount of use before posting a review
award-badge

Upgrade Pick

in Cake Pan

All-Clad Pro-Release 9" Pan
A

46 reviews

$28
·
Amazon
$28
·
williams-sonoma
$28
·
all-clad
award-badge
Best Overall Cake Pan
TechGearLab · Best Cake Pan of 2022
•
Great for baking cakes that are easy to get out of the pan intact
•
Durable and well made
•
Nonstick coating makes baking a breeze
•
Solid bakeware, very well made and durable
•
Awesome for cornbread or brownies or even lasagna
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick 9" Square
A

32 reviews

$18
·
Amazon
Save $21 (54%) *
$23
·
conwaykitchen
$23
·
kohls
award-badge
Best Square Pan
TechGearLab · Best Cake Pan of 2022
•
Great for cake and other baking
•
Heavy duty and non-stick
•
Easy to clean
•
Comes with a warranty
•
Some people find it easy to scratch
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel 13 x 9 x 2.25 Inch Rectangular Cake Pan
A

45 reviews

$26
·
Amazon
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking
•
Even cooking
•
Fabrication is somewhat less than great
•
Corners can and will rust after one use
•
In other words, not 100% USA
USA Pan 8" Round
A

39 reviews

$20
·
breadbeckers
Save $10 (33%) *
$25
·
lepetitegourmetshoppe
$30
·
Amazon
award-badge
Best Round Pan
TechGearLab · Best Cake Pan of 2022
•
Great for easy cleaning
•
Heat evenly and cool quickly
•
Heavy duty
•
Good quality
Fat Daddio's ProSeries Square Cake Pan
A

40 reviews

$21
·
Amazon
award-badge
8-Inch Square Baking Pans
America's Test Kitchen · Build the Best Sandwiches
•
Great for baking brownies and cake in a convection toaster oven
•
Hard to clean
•
Does not lose its coating
•
Quality is why customers keep coming back
•
Too small for use in an Instant Pot
Parrish Magic Square and Rectangular Pans
A

34 reviews

$27
·
Amazon
$30
·
ebay (USED)
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking
•
Scratches easy when cutting things in the pan, but expected
•
Comes with a nonstick coating
•
Lives up to expectations based on positive reviews
•
Good value for the price
Nordic Ware ­Naturals Nonstick 9" Round
A

41 reviews

$30
·
Amazon
$25
·
ebay (USED)
award-badge
The Best 9-Inch Round Cake Pans
America's Test Kitchen · Bake Impressive Desserts This Valentine’s Day
•
Great for baking cakes
•
Nice weight
•
Requires parchment paper for absolutely everything or it will stick
•
Arrived chipped and with striations on the inside
•
Definitely not Nordic quality
Parrish Magic Line Cake Pans
A

22 reviews

$4
·
cakesupplies4u
Save $5 (56%) *
$9
·
Amazon
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking cakes and other pastries
•
Sturdy construction with a nice finish
•
Easy to release cakes without sticking or breaking
•
Made in the USA
•
Quality is evident from the start
Chicago Metallic Commercial II Nonstick 9-Inch Round Cake Pan
A

32 reviews

$11
·
Amazon
Save $6 (35%) *
$17
·
homedepot
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking
•
Releases well
•
Clean up easily
•
Comes in a variety of colors
•
Stamped "Commercial II" on the bottom
Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware, Rectangular Cake Pan, 9-inch by 13-inch
A

28 reviews

$11
·
Amazon
award-badge
#15 most mentioned brand
Reddit · r/cooking
award-badge
#81 most mentioned brand
Reddit · r/BuyItForLife
award-badge
Recommended
Wirecutter · The Best Cake Pans for 2021
•
Great for baking
•
Easy to clean
•
Leaks orange rust after several washes
•
Not as sturdy as older models
•
Good value for the price