Wirecutter

The quiet, compact Spectra S1 has a rechargeable battery and separate modes for suction strength and suction speed, making it more customizable and easier to use than competitors.

BabyGearLab

The Spectra S1 is the most sought-after daily-use pump for a good reason, and it is the one we recommend to friends and family looking for an effective and quality pump. It is comfortable, efficient, and easy to use with minimal parts and a rechargeable battery, so you are not a slave to an electrical outlet. The S1 has some serious suction power up to 270 mmHg at a surprisingly friendly cost. Combined with 12 suction levels, its power creates an efficient pump that can produce more expressed milk in less time than most competitors. This pump comes completely assembled with an easy-to-understand manual. The S1 is a closed system via hygienic protectors that connect to the tubing. This setup prevents both condensation build-up in tubing and microbial growth in the motor, which means that long-term, the Spectra's inner workings remain in good shape, and breastmilk stays pristine. Best of all, the S1 is quiet, so quiet that you can pump next to a sleeping baby and husband without waking them.
Even though the S1 is a closed system, it is a single-user pump, and only one person should use it. With such efficient pumping and helpful extras like an included nightlight, a built-in timer, space to place bottle, and memory that saves the prior setting, you will get your money's worth with this pump. Overall, there is much to love about this efficient option, and we can't think of a good reason not to add it to your breastfeeding routine. 

Best for Most

amazon.com

yotpo

target

When you’re nursing (or pumping) on one breast, the silicone Haakaa vessel catches letdown from the opposite breast, saving milk that would otherwise go to waste.

Budget Pick

walmart

With a smooth, swiveling handle, the Medela Harmony is easier to grip and squeeze repeatedly than other models.

The Medela Harmony Manual pump is a simple, affordable, compact pumping system that is a great companion piece to an electric pump for occasional use like date night or overnights away from your baby. Alternatively, you may not require an electric pump at all. In that case, the Harmony can be convenient to have on hand for plugged ducts or engorgement. When your baby is on solids and down to one to two nursing sessions a day, it is also helpful for longer periods between feedings to release pressure and help with discomfort. Compared to the other manual pumps on the market, the Medela has a unique "two-phase expression," very similar to many electric pumps in this review. This feature is excellent in a manual pump as it makes pumping more comfortable without an instant sharp tug that can be very painful. The kit includes one 5 oz bottle with a stand and two 24mm PersonalFit flexible breast flanges.
Manual pumps that require frequent and repetitive hand motions can be taxing for many and impossible for some. While this pump allows for different hand positions, it is still something to consider depending on how you plan to use it. Also, it only pumps one breast at a time, so it will take longer to get the job done if you need to express both sides in one sitting. Overall, this pump is a perfect size for travel, is virtually silent, and can help busy moms in a pinch even if you won't want to use it daily. 

bazaarvoice

powerreviews

At a fourth of a pound, the Baby Buddha is well-liked for its small size, ability to wear as a necklace, and being completely untethered while pumping. Its minimal footprint has impressively strong suction at a maximum of 320 mmHg, resulting in efficient emptying for many women. In total, there are 14 settings. The rechargeable battery lasts one hour of pumping and takes 3 to 4 hours to charge through a USB port. Out of the box, it is straightforward and intuitive to use with only two buttons. It comes with a lanyard for wearing the pump, a simple carry bag, three tubes, one t-connector, collection bottles, and 24mm flanges lined with comfortable silicone.
One potential drawback to the Buddha is that some users feel the suction is too powerful, particularly in the letdown phase. Some complain it is painful. This experience isn't true for everyone, but it is something to consider if you already know you have sensitive breasts or nipples. Unfortunately, the Buddha is loud and makes a rhythmic buzzing sound you can hear over the phone and across the room. Also, the minimal user interface only measures time in minutes, not seconds, which may or may not be a problem as some competitors don't measure the time at all. Thanks to its weight, size, and power, the Buddha is a contender for those who travel, work away from home, or need to move while pumping. 

Similar in price and performance to our pick, this manual pump lacks a swiveling handle, which makes it harder to grip and squeeze.

shopify

The popular Medela Pump in Style Advanced is louder than our pick and lacks separate controls for suction strength and speed, but it’s easier to find this popular pump’s parts and accessories.

Breast Pump Comparison