Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

But if I did want to do that look, I can achieve it with this eyeliner. but so more in my comfort zone is a black eyeliner along the top lash line, so...

For those of you who are interested in buying this eyeliner, BE AWARE of the eyeliner's poor twist up ability. More than likely (50% of the time), the eyeliner's twist up segment will be broken, meaning that no matter how much you twist, the eyeliner will not come up. I recently bought mine in Lionf...

So. This Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner by Stila is ALMOST everything that I want in an eyeliner. It goes on smooth, it stays on, after a week of having and using it there is no drying out of the product or constant sharpening because of the product that is exposed doesnt transfer as well.

BUT th...

Eh, I give this product 3.5 stars. I've read countless reviews of long-wearing eyeliners and was really excited to try an eyeliner that so many have said actually stays on and doesn't create the raccoon look by the end of the day. The Stila Smudgestick is okay - I have very oily skin and most eyelin...

I am pretty loyal to Stila products, but I'm dissapointed with this eyeliner. It is *gone* by the end of my work day. I am not one to bring a bunch of makeup to work with me so I like staying power. Also, you have to twist this thing like crazy to get more out. I ended up ordering a replacement beca...

My pocketbook only knows how many brands and styles of eyeliners I've purchased from gel, to pencil, to different types of applicators and I have to say that this one made the top of my list! It really goes on so smooth and easy. The color is intense so no need to keep having to go back over your li...

I bought the Gilded and I like it very much. I'm going to try the Stingray next as a replacement for my UD pencil eyeliner, as I've heard the Stila is easier to apply. I did not have the issue others have cited with the pencil not extending. The four stars are based on how I like the eyeliner so far...

The first time I wore this eyeliner, I really liked it. It went on smoothly, it lasted all day, no issues. The second time I wore it, the eyeliner transferred to my contact lens, making my vision completely blurry in one eye. I tried cleaning the lens and putting it back in my eye, but every time it...

Bummed out because it’s pricier than some others for the average buyer, so I expected it to work well. However I’ve had cheap drugstore brands that applied better, honestly. This product doesn’t go on well, you have to go over it multiple times to get it to a decently dark line. It’s not very smooth...

Normally I LOVE this eyeliner and buy it directly from Ulta. This time I figured I’d try Amazon to save on shipping cost, I will not buy it from here again. Usually this eyeliner is soft and glides on super easily and last all day, sometimes overnight, no issues. The one I got from Amazon is super h...