Best Colourpop Creme Gel Eyeliner Alternatives

Based on reviews from amazon.com, target.com, walmart.com, nytimes.com, ulta.com, and more.

Things to consider when looking for the best Colourpop Creme Gel Eyeliner alternatives

When comparing reviews for products, these are the top things reviewers talk about:

  • Staying power: 232 mentions
  • Makeup: 105 mentions
  • Color: 69 mentions
  • Consistency: 38 mentions
  • Smudge-ability: 21 mentions
  • Application technique: 19 mentions
  • Quality: 18 mentions
  • Waterproofness: 15 mentions
  • Brush applicator: 15 mentions
  • Shade: 13 mentions
A

Based on 113 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for the price
  • Pigment is good
  • Bristles get messed up easily
  • Difficult to clean
  • Causes bubbles
A

Based on 90 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for lining the eye
  • Easy to blend
  • Dries up halfway before you've used it all
  • Vial dries out very quickly
  • Runs unless the waterline is also powdered with eyeshadow
A

Based on 50 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for long-wearing
  • Easy to apply
  • Intense color
  • Poor twist up ability
  • Goes on smooth
B

Based on 50 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for aging hooded eyes
  • Does not smudge
  • Long lasting
  • May be difficult to find in stores
  • Requires mixing with eyeshadow
B

Based on 123 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for oily eyelids
  • Easily smudges
  • Takes a long time to dry
  • Peels off easily
  • Difficult to apply
B

Based on 97 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for beginners
  • Easy to use
  • Long lasting
  • Good value for money
  • Comes in a variety of colors
B

Based on 65 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for those who want a long-wearing eyeliner
  • Tip is too long and pliant
  • Difficult to control
  • Gets all over the eyelid when applying
  • May be difficult to remove
C

Based on 7 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for bold colors and graphic eyeliner
  • Comes with a brush
  • Easy to use
  • Long lasting
  • Good value for money
C

Based on 62 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for people who like bold eyebrows
  • Goes on strong or weak
  • Not as smooth as Rimmel eyebrow duo
  • Too dark for some people
  • Taupe-Blonde color looks closer to real hair color
C

Based on 80 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for everyday use
  • Easy to apply
  • Long lasting
  • Does not smudge or fade
  • Comes in black and brown