Benchmade Altitude Fixed Blade Knife vs Gerber Vital Pocket Folding Knife Exchange-A-Blade

  • Great for hunting
  • Lightweight
  • Sharp out of the box
  • Comfortable to use
  • Very controllable
  • Great for getting the hide off an animal
  • Knife is tiny
  • Handle texture makes gripping easier with wet/bloody hands
  • Not a good knife to carry with you all the time

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Blade

Benchmade Altitude Fixed Blade Knife
So I have 170$ to spend but don’t know what to get, any suggestions?( not brands but actual knives, I’m between spiderco and benchmade)
Benchmade 15200 Altitude. You might have to shop around to find one at your price, but they can be found. Amazing little fixed blade that is great at holding an edge
PositivePositive
1
eltacotacotaco
2 years ago
reddit.com/r/knives
Read more
Gerber Vital Pocket Folding Knife Exchange-A-Blade
Not for real men
Background on me(not bragging just fyi for you) 12 years meat cutter. Wanted to try something new so I bought this vital pocket knife I'll start with the good...changeable blades great idea...! The blades do not stay sharp! Went through 3 blades gutting and skinning whitetail. During that time blade...
1/5
Joe Muff
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Handle

Benchmade Altitude Fixed Blade Knife
Sharp and light!
Handles well, this knife is awesome especially for my sheep and mule deer prairie hunts where I carry a lot of gear. I didn't know if i'd like the orange but it's great, you never have to look for it. Great purchase
5/5
Canadianhunter1
3 years ago
cabelas.com
Read more
Gerber Vital Pocket Folding Knife Exchange-A-Blade
Better than just a knife
PROS: Light weight Lock back design Easy/safe blade swaps Compact/easy to carry Cuts extremely well (on game/fish) Looks cool CONS: Not made for left handers Half the blade is useless Basically an expensive scalpel handle Hard to clean Overall, you could save your money and buy a #13 scalpel handle ...
4/5
Eric G.
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Durability

Benchmade Altitude Fixed Blade Knife
Top notch
Top notch knife. I havent used it for hunting yet but this thing is ultra-light and very durable
5/5
Thomas Martin
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more
Gerber Vital Pocket Folding Knife Exchange-A-Blade
Written because of some of the other reviews...
I have used this knife for perhaps the last five or so years; I was introduced to it by a hunting buddy. Most of what I use it on is moose and caribou, with the occasional bear. I find it to be a very good knife for getting the hide off the animal. Some of the complaints I have seen - that prompted ...
5/5
AK_Taxidermist
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Price/value Ratio

Benchmade Altitude Fixed Blade Knife
Benchmade Does It Again.
This is a spendy knife but it is well worth the price. I purchased the firstlite edition knife because it is $30 cheaper on Amazon than anywhere else at the moment.
5/5
Hollibaugh
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Gerber Vital Pocket Folding Knife Exchange-A-Blade
Where does the money go?
I dislike like this product and was severely disappointed with it. My main complaint is that it is tiny. The whole knife is around 4 1/4 inch folded but the full usable blade is only 1.36 inch. Absolutely tiny! It is stiff to open and auto closes meaning it is difficult to both open with one hand an...
2/5
Phill Morgan
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more