Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot vs Tingley Storm Stretch Overshoe

  • Great for wet and slushy weather
  • Original design, the Caribou, is a better snow boot than most
  • Tied loose and slipped them on and off for years
  • MOST DISAPPOINTED.
  • Should have listened to some of the other reviewers about quality
  • Great for wet weather
  • Fits well over shoes
  • Easy to put on
  • Protects shoes from water and snow
  • Good for people with disabilities

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Fit

Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Not like Sorel boots from the 80s
I've owned a pair of Sorel Caribous since the early 80's. Tied them loose and slipped them on and off for years. Changed the liners 3 times during this period. Feet never got cold even on the coldest days. Got the new boots, tried them on and the fit was perfect. Toes had room for any socks I chose ...
1/5
Bob H
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Tingley Storm Stretch Overshoe
Good dress shoe cover, but buy the next size up.
Like other reviews have said, buy the next size up. I wear a men's 10 1/2 EEE. I bought the XL size for 11 - 13 mens. They fit perfectly, not lose at all and not too tight. So far I'm happy. Also, this product is intended for Dress Shoes, NOT sneakers. The XL size does not fit my 10 1/2 EE Asics but...
4/5
Ohio Guy
8 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Size

Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Do not buy from this seller!!!
I received the incorrect size upon receiving my order. I wore them twice before realizing the mistake (thinking that I just had to break them in). Now the seller has my returned boots and won’t refund me since they are slightly worn. They said they would return the boots back to me, but I really jus...
1/5
SDShubert
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Tingley Storm Stretch Overshoe
Good dress shoe cover, but buy the next size up.
Like other reviews have said, buy the next size up. I wear a men's 10 1/2 EEE. I bought the XL size for 11 - 13 mens. They fit perfectly, not lose at all and not too tight. So far I'm happy. Also, this product is intended for Dress Shoes, NOT sneakers. The XL size does not fit my 10 1/2 EE Asics but...
4/5
Ohio Guy
8 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Style

Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
youtube
Why is There No Positive Reviews of Sorel Caribou Boot? (CUT IN HALF)
for farmers and hunters in Canada, it's somewhere stuck between those worlds, and it doesn't seem like it does either one very well anymore, and that might be just to save the brand to drop the price and make it an accessible boot for a lot of people to sell more boots. And it just lacks the specialization that Sorel originally was known for. But I wouldn't necessarily say this is a bad boot
NegativeNegative
Rose Anvil
an hour ago
youtube.com
Read more
Tingley Storm Stretch Overshoe
Extremely practical, cheap, and not too bad looking
I keep these in my work backpack everyday, stuffed in a 3L stuff sack; they're light enough and well worth the space for the added freedom and peace of mind. The tall sides and tongue and the sturdy tread of these galoshes provide fairly good coverage in the rain and when walking through puddles. Th...
5/5
A Reviewer
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Comfort

Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
These are my favorite snow boots for surviving New England winters
When I first announced I was moving to Boston three years ago, my mother—who had spent her college years in Beantown—advised that I immediately invest in a heavier winter coat and quality snow boots. She was right. While I had grown up in Connecticut, I quickly learned that winter is a bit more inte...
Tingley Storm Stretch Overshoe
The Secret to a Good Rubber Overshoe Fit
These rubber loafers are a real life saver for me. I can't wear snow/rain boots due to a disability. The overshoes fit easily over my custom-made shoes, with tread keeps me safe when walking city sidewalks on sloppy weather days. This type of overshoe is designed to fit snugly, but because Tingleys ...
5/5
Scott NYC
9 years ago
amazon.com
Read more