What is Looria?Sign up

Fitness Tracker

Fitbit One vs Withings Steel HR

Fitbit One

48 reviews

View Product Details

Withings Steel HR

Withings Steel HR

63 reviews

View Product Details

Wirecutter · The Best 3 Smartwatches for Android Phones 2021

Great customer service

Small size and easy to clip onto clothing

Reliable tracking of steps and sleep

Longevity of the device

Ease of use and simple app interface

Great battery life (up to 30 days per charge)

Stylish design

Comfortable to wear

Reliable and accurate heart rate tracking

Accurate sleep tracking

Not ideal for tracking certain activities, such as biking or weightlifting

No heart rate monitoring

Some users prefer a wristband option

Not the best choice for those looking for a comprehensive fitness tracker

Limited fitness tracking capabilities

No GPS tracking

Verdict

The Fitbit One receives mixed reviews from users, with some praising its accuracy and ease of use, while others criticize its limitations in tracking certain activities. Many users appreciate its small size and ability to clip onto clothing, but some prefer a wristband option. The company's customer service is generally praised, and the device's longevity is noted by some long-time users. Overall, the Fitbit One is seen as a reliable option for tracking steps and sleep, but may not be the best choice for those looking to track more specific activities or heart rate.

Verdict

The Withings Steel HR is a stylish hybrid smartwatch that offers basic fitness tracking capabilities. It is comfortable to wear and has good battery life, lasting up to 30 days per charge. The heart rate tracking contributes to the Steel HR Sport’s sleep tracking, which is reliable and accurate. However, it may not be the best choice for those looking for a more comprehensive fitness tracker.

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Activity Tracking

youtube

Fitbit one- Fitbit reviews

And then since getting this Fitbit, the Fitbit is just easier to use, it's smaller to fit in your pocket or clip, the accessories seem of higher quali...

Positive

youtube

Maybe This WASN'T The Best Choice - My First Smartwatch

So that's pretty awesome and the only physical interaction you have is the side button to see your time, your heart, break, distance and battery life ...

Positive

Battery Life

Surprisingly Accurate

HOWEVER, it should be noted that something like Runkeeper is very intensive on your phone's battery life, and it generally will not work indoors or in any situation where it can't get a stable GPS signal. The One is appealing it that it's a clip-it-and-forget-it type measuring device; once you attach it to yourself, you can pretty much just go about your business as you normally would and not worry about it until you need to change your clothes, and it will faithfully record everything. The downside to that is .

Withings Steel HR review: Your everyday watch with heart rate

I could see my wife was calling. I couldn't read what her previous text was. Most watch features don't need the second screen. Sarah Tew/CNETThe best part of Steel HR might be battery life

Neutral

Notifications

The "Dashboard" is my motivation!

Anyway - knowing this thing is attached to me (I wear it clipped inside my bra), waiting for me to DO something, is rather motivating because unlike my pedometer, I get SO much more feedback. A quick glance at a bar graph for the week, showing calories eaten and calories burned, tells me if I'm on the right track. I LIKE that and find it motivating. The sleep monitor is interesting - as other reviewers have said - it simply charts any movement during the night

Beautiful concept, disappointing implementation...

Third, literally the ONLY messages you get notifications for are SMS messages, and even then, only if you are using the stock text-messaging app. No WhatsApp, no Signal, no Facebook Messenger, no Google Hangouts, nothing. Effectively, this watch is utterly useless at the single most important function a smartwatch can provide! 3) The smart wakeup feature depends upon the watch’s alarm. They aren’t joking about the “Alarm” part, either

Design

Steps work, not so great with app, sleep, or stairs-updated

Update- I'm keeping it, so I raised my review to four stars. Alarm- I like that I can set an alarm for the mornings I have to get up early and leave it set, without worrying about the days I don't have to get up. Conclusion- maybe one tracker just can't do everything well, but the Fitbit people really need to create a better, more elegant app. What would make sense to me on the sleep activity is if you could adjust it (say with a slider) after a night of sleep so that what it report reflects what you know is true (amount of waking for example) and then it would be more accurate

Here’s a story spanning three gadgets, two brands, and one pretty great fitness app

Their subtle gamification and classy design turned me from a fitness app hater into someone who tracks his weight, body composition, steps, and sleep on a daily basis and is actively enjoying the whole thing.

Positive

QUICK QUESTION!

Got an opinion on a product you've used?
If so, we want to hear from you! Write an authentic longevity review about the product and share your experience with our community. You'll have the chance to win a $100 gift card.

You might also like

More Alternatives

Fitbit Inspire 2

Fitbit Inspire 2

Garmin Forerunner 35

Garmin Forerunner 35

Fitbit Charge 4

Fitbit Charge 4

Withings Steel HR

Withings Steel HR

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 5

Fitbit Charge 5

More Alternatives