What is Looria?Sign up

Fitness Tracker

Fitbit Charge 5 vs Amazon Halo

Fitbit Charge 5

Fitbit Charge 5

287 reviews

View Product Details

Amazon Halo

127 reviews

View Product Details

Wirecutter · The 4 Best Fitness Trackers 2021

Great design and comfortable to wear

Tracks steps, sleep, and other activities

Decent battery life

Affordable price point

Mindfulness sessions available with premium subscription

Great activity tracking with flexible and simple goals

Unique features such as tone analysis and body fat measurement

Long battery life

Not the best choice for runners or outdoor activities due to unreliable GPS connectivity

Premium subscription required to access some features

Battery life could be better

Not as comfortable to wear as other fitness trackers

Lacking in accuracy compared to other fitness trackers

Monthly subscription fee is a point of contention for some users

Verdict

The Fitbit Charge 5 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for an all-around device that can track steps, sleep, and other activities. It has a sleek design and is comfortable to wear. The battery life is decent, but could be better. The GPS connectivity is unreliable, so it may not be the best choice for runners or outdoor activities. However, it's still a great option for tracking your daily activity and monitoring your health.

Verdict

Overall, the Amazon Halo has received mixed reviews. While some users appreciate its unique features such as tone analysis and body fat measurement, others find it uncomfortable to wear and lacking in accuracy compared to other fitness trackers. The monthly subscription fee is also a point of contention for some users. However, for basic activity and sleep tracking, the Halo is on par with similar devices in its class.

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Connectivity

Good for most common uses but GPS connection is lacking.

Edit: I ended up sending the device back because the GPS is so unreliable. Maybe there's another FItBit model with better GPS connectivity, but this particular one isn't going to work for me.

It makes a 3D model of your body and tracks the emotional tone in your voice

It communicates with your phone via Bluetooth, and it should work equally well with both iPhones and Android phones. The three main band colors that will be sold are onyx (black), mineral (light blue), and rose gold (pink-ish).

Positive

Fit

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 review: Why you're MISSING OUT if you're not wearing this smart fitness tracker

Fitbit has basically become a household name in the tracker health monitor field, but the company hasn't been resting on its laurels. They continue to...

Positive

youtube

Amazon’s new Halo View fitness band seems a lot less creepy than last year.

There are a lot of other color screen fitness bands out there. You can look for them on amazon, for instance. Well, the halo view is going very compet...

Positive

Activity Tracking

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 Review - still worth it in 2022?

The while for its price, the Fitbit Charge 5 offers a lot. It won't be the perfect fit for everyone. With limited workout tracking features and a less...

Positive

youtube

Amazon Halo View review: A $80 Fitbit competitor

The halo view checks a lot of the boxes. You'D want from a basic fitness tracker, especially for less than a hundred dollars, but the big question is ...

Positive

Comfortability

Fitbit charge 5 or garmin vivo 4 or other (Polar)? Focus on general wellness (F26)

I can comment on the Charge 5 comfort - it's amazing, I have it on 24/7 and don't even know it's there.

Positive

reddit.com/r/fitbit

Amazon Halo Review

The corrective exercise videos are relaxing and enjoyable. Physical therapy doctor Kelly Starrett leads you through the exercises while explaining the purpose of each move and demonstrating proper form. You perform each move twice, for about 30 seconds per round.

Positive

Comfort

Back to Fitbit… Kind of….

The Fitbit Charge 5 is better in every way except form/fit. As long as you can stand something on your wrist, I highly advise against the Oura ring.

Negative

reddit.com/r/fitbit

Love it - Negative reviews seem like they didn’t read before buying

Other sleep stuff:
I’m a good sleeper already, so I don’t pay a ton of attention to the sleep aid stuff they have, but my husband uses it when he can’t fall asleep even though he doesn’t wear the band! Seeing the sleep stats each morning is pretty interesting to me though, and I look them over when I eat breakfast.

No face:
I don’t like smart watches, and I don’t want a watch face.

Comfort:
Other negative things I’ve seen claim it’s bulky and has to be worn super tight or it clanks around. Absolutely not true

Notifications

Brighter screen, but for me an overall downgrade.

So, when I walked the neighborhood loop to my house, it really is nice when my Charge 4 let me know that I also did the equivalent of about 10 flights of stairs with each loop. Without the altimeter, that information cannot be shown.

Technology in search of a problem

I can only imagine what that does to your battery. What would be great here is a little vibraty notification on the device itself when you go negative. Some sort of subtle reminder that hey, maybe your tone isn't what you want at the moment. That would be so much more useful than hours later being told you did something wrong

Price

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 In-Depth Review: 9 New Things to Know

And today we've got a complete review of the new FitBit Charge 5, as well as nine new things to know about this unit. Now, I've been using it for a wh...

Neutral

There are some great features, but not the innovative ones you're hoping for.

If I had to spend $100 to get the device today I doubt I would pull the trigger. If I have to start paying for the features I like in the Halo app, forget it. I'll just get a Fitbit.

Battery Life

Is fitbit dodgy?

Then there's the disgusting battery life which seems to be caused by bad software. 7+ days battery life advertised on the box but it barely gets 24 hours with even with features turned off.

Negative

reddit.com/r/fitbit

A nice try, but lacking in key features...

One of the primary drawbacks from the Active was the short battery life. Having to take off your smartwatch and charge it every day or so makes it hard to get into the habit of actually wearing the darn thing. If you don't use the Tone feature (more on that in a moment), the Halo lasts a good 3-4 days per charge. That's fine, but with no display of any sort, no GPS, and a lack of other common sensors, it seems as though Amazon's engineers should have been able to get a week out of this thing, at least

Durability

Poor out of box experience, Spo2 issues

One downside is the apparent need to sign up for an expensive membership, but I figured I'd give it a year and let the Fitbit ecosystem prove its value. The trouble started almost immediately when I unboxed the device and went through the initial setup. Total PTSD, from previous attempts to use Fitbit hardware & software. Here, the device kept failing to perform the initial software update

Average, Interesting & Concerning

I'm reviewing this as a basic fitness tracker on par with entry level Fitbits, Garmins and similar devices. This is not a high level or even medium level exercise and training tool. If you are looking for higher level tracking and analysis of overall health, recovery and exertion during a training session, this is not the device.

As a basic movement and sleep tracker I found it operates on par with similar devices

Design

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 review

In a world filled with smartwatches, fitness trackers feel kind of liberating. They're smaller, they generally have better battery life, and they're e...

Positive

Has some useful features but its not there yet

(Doing this by body composition alone I am not sure is a good measure of health)

Also you can not stream the labs to a TV, so watching them on your phone sucks to be honest. Also the workouts in the labs you can probably find for free on youtube if you really wanted to.

I think one design improvement is to have a swap-able battery so you can charge one and have one on the band. Although this is not a huge deal for me as the charging is pretty fast but some might find it important

Software Updates

Grumpy Coach and Salesman included with every purchase!

- the time needed to update and sync between FB5 and app is almost instantaneous when the app is opened and is a great change - no more, "hold, this is taking longer than expected" and sometimes having to restart the process on the FB3

Maybe worth it at a discount? Buyer beware of this first-gen product however!

I had to factory reset it after all, which did clear out any data collected since the last time it synced but fortunately everything else on my profile appears to have been restored. There was a firmware update immediately available for the Halo, and it applied successfully. I'm not sure how often it updates itself in the background (e.g

QUICK QUESTION!

Got an opinion on a product you've used?
If so, we want to hear from you! Write an authentic longevity review about the product and share your experience with our community. You'll have the chance to win a $100 gift card.

You might also like

More Alternatives

Fitbit Inspire 2

Fitbit Inspire 2

Garmin Forerunner 35

Garmin Forerunner 35

Fitbit Charge 4

Fitbit Charge 4

Withings Steel HR

Withings Steel HR

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 5

Fitbit Charge 5

More Alternatives