Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot vs Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot

  • Great for people who are on their feet all day
  • Comfortable and easy to put on
  • Lightweight and affordable
  • Good traction
  • Easy to clean
  • Great for wet and slushy weather
  • Original design, the Caribou, is a better snow boot than most
  • Tied loose and slipped them on and off for years
  • MOST DISAPPOINTED.
  • Should have listened to some of the other reviewers about quality

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Fit

Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Cushy foam rubber feeling. But comfortable? They just don't fit well [based on ordering two pairs].
I compared at least 6 different rain boots, mud boots and different sizes in some. They were sizes 9, 10, 11 etc. Depends on the manufacturer: For our purposes here I will compare size 10 in: 1. Seac 6mm, 2. Guide Gear, 3. Crocs AllCast [Sizes 9 & 10], 4. Hisea, 5. Servus Comfort tech, 6. LaCrosse D...
3/5
My Daughters' Daddy
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Not like Sorel boots from the 80s
I've owned a pair of Sorel Caribous since the early 80's. Tied them loose and slipped them on and off for years. Changed the liners 3 times during this period. Feet never got cold even on the coldest days. Got the new boots, tried them on and the fit was perfect. Toes had room for any socks I chose ...
1/5
Bob H
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Size

Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Cushy foam rubber feeling. But comfortable? They just don't fit well [based on ordering two pairs].
I compared at least 6 different rain boots, mud boots and different sizes in some. They were sizes 9, 10, 11 etc. Depends on the manufacturer: For our purposes here I will compare size 10 in: 1. Seac 6mm, 2. Guide Gear, 3. Crocs AllCast [Sizes 9 & 10], 4. Hisea, 5. Servus Comfort tech, 6. LaCrosse D...
3/5
My Daughters' Daddy
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Do not buy from this seller!!!
I received the incorrect size upon receiving my order. I wore them twice before realizing the mistake (thinking that I just had to break them in). Now the seller has my returned boots and won’t refund me since they are slightly worn. They said they would return the boots back to me, but I really jus...
1/5
SDShubert
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Comfort

Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Comfy
I am a lawn technician and I am walking on lawns all day and these are by far the most comfortable boots I ever warn and I have been doing this for 8 years. They are a bit of a pain to put on but I don't think it's a big deal I'll sacrifice couple seconds too putting them on to have comfort.
5/5
Daniel
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Excellent snow boots!
These are best snow boots I have ever bought. When I first got them they seemed to feel "slightly" small, but after wearing them a few times they have loosened up. I'm size 11, and they now feel right on the money. Another thing, you want the insulating material to come together when you lace up. Do...
5/5
PacNW
6 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Style

Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
I'll give these a shot
I'll give these a shot. To be honest I never liked the look of Croc's I always thought they looked sort of sloppy, no matter how comfortable people said they were. These boots were the first product that looked handsome, are more than comfortable, lightweight, and do what they say; which is to keep ...
5/5
Sergio Vancari
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more
Sorel Men’s Caribou Boot
Junk. Soles are paper thin plastic. 👎🏻
Junk. These aren’t the Sorels I grew up with. I sold these 20 years ago and loved them. I gave mine to a friend and many years later found myself needing a fresh pair. Sorel stopped making them in Canada and now make them in China. The soles feel plastic. Not the dense vulcanized rubber of old. Fine...
1/5
paul saavedra
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more