CRKT Minimalist cleaver vs ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife

  • Great for camping and survival
  • Sharp out of the box
  • Feels great in hand
  • Packaging is simple but satisfying to open
  • Design is killer
  • Great for light work around an office
  • Good quality
  • Hold an edge well
  • Gripping the handle is like gripping a slippery hard piece of plastic
  • Very cool color combination

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Weight

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
Topic of the Week - Week of February 22, 2021 - Packing your fears
Through many others, I finally have been using the CRKT minimalist and actually just ordered a SpyderCo LadyBug (supposed to be about 15 g). I don’t think I’ll ever be someone who ditches a knife completely or goes the razor blade route, but I’ve definitely shaved a lot of weight over the years.
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
Love the New Scales
I got the ESEE 4 in the mail last week. It is everything ESEE is supposed to be. Great looks, excellent fit and finish, crazy sharp straight from the box. I have had an ESSE 5 for a few years so I already know how good their knives are, but the new 3D scales take it to another level. The ESEE 4 is a...
5/5
camoguy
2 years ago
smkw.com
Read more

Blade

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
CRKT Minimalist Cleaver
The packaging was simple but very nice. It was a green CRKT small box that had the brand written in white. Sturdy cardboard and very satisfying to open. The unit inside was placed inside a plastic sleeve in it's plastic carry sheath. It came with a belt clip and lanyard and can only be mounted longw...
5/5
Ryan M.
1 year ago
smkw.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
Excellent all around Choice for a High Quality Knife
Let me preface this by saying I am not a "knife guy" but I do appreciate the need for a good blade while hiking, camping, or even just to toss in the glove-box. I didn't want a throwaway utility knife, or something made in china from a box store, but something I can look forward to owning for years ...
5/5
Adam Mikolajczyk
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Handle

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
Outer layer of handle wears thin.
The outer layer of the handle is so thin that it is worn through in multiple spots straight from the seller. It gives the handle of the knife a very shop-worn appearance right out of the box. It makes it look like someone has used the handle portion of the knife for a long time.
2/5
Amazon Customer
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
Awesome knife but the 3D handles are iffy
I have several ESEE knives and think they are great quality, good steel, hold an edge well, pretty much everything you could hope for in a working knife. My particular beef with the version I got here is these new 3D handles. They are like gripping a slippery hard piece of plastic. I have micarta ha...
3/5
PK
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Price/value Ratio

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
CRKT Minimalist Cleaver
The packaging was simple but very nice. It was a green CRKT small box that had the brand written in white. Sturdy cardboard and very satisfying to open. The unit inside was placed inside a plastic sleeve in it's plastic carry sheath. It came with a belt clip and lanyard and can only be mounted longw...
5/5
Ryan M.
1 year ago
smkw.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
My favorite Esee model of them all
This is my 5th Esee knife and I’m sure not the last. Very cool color combination. These guys know how to make durable knives. Don’t bother wasting your money on more expensive brands. Esee is what you want!
5/5
Rick Holliday
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Material

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
Good stuff, but room to improve
The design is killer. Potential to be one of the safest camping and survivalist knives one could get for its size. Two downsides I see: -Bead-blast finish is nice, but prevents the spline from being effectively used as a striker for ferrous rods. A quick run over the back with a sanding bit on my dr...
5/5
Rumble righteously
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
Awesome knife but the 3D handles are iffy
I have several ESEE knives and think they are great quality, good steel, hold an edge well, pretty much everything you could hope for in a working knife. My particular beef with the version I got here is these new 3D handles. They are like gripping a slippery hard piece of plastic. I have micarta ha...
3/5
PK
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Sheath

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
Great little knife. Would make a great gift.
Great little knife. Comes razor sharp. Sheath is secure but if I comes loose I will just heat the plastic and push together to make it tighter again. Highly recommended, especially for under $30. Also very small so keep that in mind.
5/5
Jovana Muñoz
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
Top Quality.
I knew the moment I held this thing that it was worth every penny.. before even taking it out of the sheathe I was impressed by the quality. the sheath works EXTREMELY well and definitely holds the knife in... it's not coming out unless you want it to. the clip attachment included with the sheathe h...
5/5
Megatron
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Durability

CRKT Minimalist cleaver
Great little knife. Would make a great gift.
Great little knife. Comes razor sharp. Sheath is secure but if I comes loose I will just heat the plastic and push together to make it tighter again. Highly recommended, especially for under $30. Also very small so keep that in mind.
5/5
Jovana Muñoz
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more
ESEE Knives ESEE-4PDT-005 Fixed Blade Knife
My favorite Esee model of them all
This is my 5th Esee knife and I’m sure not the last. Very cool color combination. These guys know how to make durable knives. Don’t bother wasting your money on more expensive brands. Esee is what you want!
5/5
Rick Holliday
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more