Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket vs Madewell The Chelsea Rain Boot

  • Great for summer showers
  • Not for cold weathers
  • Basic raincoat, not for winter
  • Waterproof and water resistant
  • Fabric is noisy
  • Made for walking in the rain
  • Comfortable, easy on / off
  • Easy to slip on; fits true to size if slightly big
  • Will have to return

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Fit

Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket
Perfect for summer showers.
I like this raincoat. Perfect for summer showers. I love that it’s water proof and not just water resistant. It does fit loose, I ordered a medium and feel like I could have gotten a small, but the medium fits good and comfortable. I love that it unzips from the bottom too so you can keep it closed ...
5/5
Spades
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Madewell The Chelsea Rain Boot
Size downize down
I usually wear a size 7 but when I got the size 7, it was a huge. I would size down if possible. I returned it for a 6 and it was a better fit. I would have also preferred if the ankle opening was smaller. The boots did keep my feet dry during a rainy day but not sure if it's suitable for snow.
3/5
annie l.
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Comfort

Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket
Good looking waterproof lightweight jacket. great for layering
Bought this for my daughter . She loves it. She needed a lightweight waterproof jacket that she could wear sweaters or sweats shirts under or tshirts in the spring. Has a nice large hood without looking bad. Perfect length .
5/5
Girl Friday
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Madewell The Chelsea Rain Boot
True to size and comfy
I tried a couple different brands this season and these were the nicest and most comfortable. I went with my true size of 8.
5/5
Janet J
9 months ago
amazon.com
Read more