Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket vs Duluth Trading Women's No-Yank Shelf Bra Tank

  • Great for summer showers
  • Not for cold weathers
  • Basic raincoat, not for winter
  • Waterproof and water resistant
  • Fabric is noisy
  • Great for wearing tucked in or out
  • Comfortable and soft
  • Doesn't roll up or ride up
  • Does a great job of keeping the bra from moving around
  • Recommended to friends

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Style

Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket
This is a newer version and that matters!
So...I first had ordered the Arcadia with adjustable waist and the small was way too small and the medium fit but adjusted to allow a fleece layer it made me look like a sausage, and the sleeves reached just above my fingernails. I now realize that this model is a newer version. The sleeves have Vel...
5/5
Cesca Lyons
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Duluth Trading Women's No-Yank Shelf Bra Tank
Perfect
Baught this for my adult daughter. She is thrilled and this mom likes the way it looks on her
5/5
Bon
7 months ago
dwxinwen.com
Read more

Fit

Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket
Perfect for summer showers.
I like this raincoat. Perfect for summer showers. I love that it’s water proof and not just water resistant. It does fit loose, I ordered a medium and feel like I could have gotten a small, but the medium fits good and comfortable. I love that it unzips from the bottom too so you can keep it closed ...
5/5
Spades
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Duluth Trading Women's No-Yank Shelf Bra Tank
I Tried the Duluth Trading Company No-Yank Tank
What Really Sold Me. I think the thing that sold me on this tank though is the fact that it stayed put at the neckline.
PositivePositive
5 months ago
jkstyle.com
Read more

Comfort

Columbia Women’s Arcadia Casual Jacket
Good looking waterproof lightweight jacket. great for layering
Bought this for my daughter . She loves it. She needed a lightweight waterproof jacket that she could wear sweaters or sweats shirts under or tshirts in the spring. Has a nice large hood without looking bad. Perfect length .
5/5
Girl Friday
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Duluth Trading Women's No-Yank Shelf Bra Tank
I Tried the Duluth Trading Company No-Yank Tank
What Really Sold Me. I think the thing that sold me on this tank though is the fact that it stayed put at the neckline.
PositivePositive
5 months ago
jkstyle.com
Read more