Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Fit

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket
Nicely Made (and a word for you if you're on the L/XL line)
I am on the border of large and x-large with most my clothes (36" give or take waist). From other reviews, I read it's a little big, so decided to size down and went for the large. It fits nice with a t-shirt underneath, but not a lot of extra room for my... ugh... expanded mid section. With a fleec...
5/5
Raymond Larose
5 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Pendleton The Original Westerley
I am one happy Dude with this sweater!
Like many people looking at this item, I'm a big fan of The Big Lebowski, and since I got a shiny new credit card, I figured I'd spend the $200+ on this iconic sweater. It's a steep price for something made in China, but this is a significant item, in more ways than one. First off, you will instantl...
5/5
Yoda Pagoda
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Size

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket
Bad Sizing
I ordered the 2x and was very disappointed in the sizing. The jacket is tight for an outerwear product. The store near me does not carry this jacket in stock, so I cannot try on a 3x to compare the difference between sizes. Also from appearance the jacket does not look and feel like it will hold up ...
2/5
cgill
4 years ago
cabelas.com
Read more
Pendleton The Original Westerley
Awesome sweater and order down a size
I've had my eye on this sweater for a long time and finally picked it up on a nice sale. Was very surprised by the weight of it upon trying it on, it is heavy without feeling cumbersome, and is certainly very warm. Was also very surprised that the sweater runs large, I generally order a 3xl for jack...
5/5
Boba Fatt
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more

Style

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket
FINALLY
Columbia products are almost always solid quality. I’m a tall, gangly guy, so finding anything with long sleeves that actually has the right proportion has almost always proven a challenge. That’s why I had familiarized myself with returns process before this jacket came because I wasn’t expecting i...
5/5
JM Swanson
1 month ago
amazon.com
Read more
Pendleton The Original Westerley
I'll tell you what I'm blathering about... I've got information man!
Well... Been wanting this for a long time. The Mrs. wouldn't get it for me for multiple years of Bdays/Christmas, so When It dropped near a $100 in price (Mid Nov 2020), I got myself a gift! As stated in multiple reviews: - I ordered down a size. Normally a XL for outerwear/sweaters, got a large and...
5/5
AFWxman
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Price

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket
NOT Fake, Check Columbia's Website for Variances
I received a jacket that did not have the Omnitech logo, rather just the letters. My 'Columbia' was an applique rather than embroidered. After reading the review about the fake one, I was affraid I fell victim too. However, I went to the Columbia website and zoomed in on different colors. These are ...
5/5
HambyJay
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Pendleton The Original Westerley
Well, this is just my opinion, man
I usually wear a 3X-tall t-shirt, ordered this in 2X as advised and it fits fine. Great feel. Looks like the price went up $100 in the week since I bought it? That's a bummer, man. Still need a new rug.
5/5
Mark Zieg
6 months ago
amazon.com
Read more

Comfort

Columbia Men’s Watertight II Jacket
Perfect Fit LargeTall 6'2" 185LB
Bought as a gift for family member and given when they visited today. He is 6'2"-6'3", 185lbs, the jacket fits with enough room to be worn over a couple layers (or not) and still be form fitting. The columbia jacket is light and comfortable material (soft feeling), also the jacket is quiet when walk...
5/5
Ann C.
3 months ago
amazon.com
Read more
Pendleton The Original Westerley
I am one happy Dude with this sweater!
Like many people looking at this item, I'm a big fan of The Big Lebowski, and since I got a shiny new credit card, I figured I'd spend the $200+ on this iconic sweater. It's a steep price for something made in China, but this is a significant item, in more ways than one. First off, you will instantl...
5/5
Yoda Pagoda
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more