Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat vs Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot

  • Great for cold weather
  • Runs small
  • Not as warm as other boots
  • Comfortable
  • Great for people who are on their feet all day
  • Comfortable and easy to put on
  • Lightweight and affordable
  • Good traction
  • Easy to clean

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Size

Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat
Order 1 to 1.5 sizes up!
I can not emphasize this enough: this boot DOES run small I like everyone claims. I thought for sure these people were crazy. Really?? Order one full size larger?? Yes ladies, at least one full size larger. I almost always wear 9.5. Rarely 9, rarely 10. I ordered 10.5 and with my regular semi-thick ...
5/5
joanna
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Cushy foam rubber feeling. But comfortable? They just don't fit well [based on ordering two pairs].
I compared at least 6 different rain boots, mud boots and different sizes in some. They were sizes 9, 10, 11 etc. Depends on the manufacturer: For our purposes here I will compare size 10 in: 1. Seac 6mm, 2. Guide Gear, 3. Crocs AllCast [Sizes 9 & 10], 4. Hisea, 5. Servus Comfort tech, 6. LaCrosse D...
3/5
My Daughters' Daddy
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Fit

Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat
Order 1 to 1.5 sizes up!
I can not emphasize this enough: this boot DOES run small I like everyone claims. I thought for sure these people were crazy. Really?? Order one full size larger?? Yes ladies, at least one full size larger. I almost always wear 9.5. Rarely 9, rarely 10. I ordered 10.5 and with my regular semi-thick ...
5/5
joanna
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Cushy foam rubber feeling. But comfortable? They just don't fit well [based on ordering two pairs].
I compared at least 6 different rain boots, mud boots and different sizes in some. They were sizes 9, 10, 11 etc. Depends on the manufacturer: For our purposes here I will compare size 10 in: 1. Seac 6mm, 2. Guide Gear, 3. Crocs AllCast [Sizes 9 & 10], 4. Hisea, 5. Servus Comfort tech, 6. LaCrosse D...
3/5
My Daughters' Daddy
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Style

Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat
Love these warm, lightweight, waterproof snow boots!
Holy cow, these boots are amazing!!! I wore them in Mammoth in 10 feet of fresh powder with occasional negative degree temperatures, and my feet were so nice and toasty! They’re rated for -25 F and I believe it. I wore a single pair of wool socks and couldn’t have asked for warmer feet. I even bough...
5/5
Victoria Elias
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
I'll give these a shot
I'll give these a shot. To be honest I never liked the look of Croc's I always thought they looked sort of sloppy, no matter how comfortable people said they were. These boots were the first product that looked handsome, are more than comfortable, lightweight, and do what they say; which is to keep ...
5/5
Sergio Vancari
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more

Comfort

Columbia Heavenly Omni-Heat
Warm and low profile!
Imagine living in Minnesota for 20 years and never owning a proper pair of winter get-around boots. That was me until today. These warm bois are great! Tested them today on ice and about 7" of snow in 28° weather. Wore them to hike around a nature preserve looking for my runaway cat for hours and fe...
5/5
jennifer sandwich
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Crocs Men’s AllCast Rain Boot
Comfy
I am a lawn technician and I am walking on lawns all day and these are by far the most comfortable boots I ever warn and I have been doing this for 8 years. They are a bit of a pain to put on but I don't think it's a big deal I'll sacrifice couple seconds too putting them on to have comfort.
5/5
Daniel
4 years ago
amazon.com
Read more