Astral Loyak Water Shoes vs Bogs Arcata Knit Boot

  • Great for walking
  • Good looking shoes
  • Fit is small, but can be fixed with a larger size
  • Insole needs to be removed
  • Shoes are worth the price
  • Great for wide feet
  • Comfortable
  • Easy to slip on and off
  • Sturdy, durable, and waterproof
  • Beautiful form and function

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Comfort

Astral Loyak Water Shoes
Best Water Shoes of 2022 - GearLab
Don't be fooled by the casual, stylish looks of the Astral Loyak. These are high-performing water shoes with a well-designed, sock-like fit, superb drainage, and sticky, siped outsoles. They are super comfortable on foot, whether in the water or on land. Their thin, neutral soles have a great ground...
PositivePositive
OutdoorGearLab
9 months ago
outdoorgearlab.com
Read more
Bogs Arcata Knit Boot
Great for wide feet
I have wide feet (thanks, dad) so it’s hard for me to find a sturdy shoe that doesn’t crush the side of my foot (it’s the side, not so much my toe box). Anyway, I buy bogs for my boys (because they are amazing), and someone had “warned” in a review that these ran wide, which is great news for me. I ...
5/5
Karmen
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Fit

Astral Loyak Water Shoes
Measure your foot, order true size (may be smaller than street shoe size)
I typically wear street or hiking shoes that are size 9-9.5, but I intended to wear the Loyak's without socks and wanted a tight fit so I measured my foot and purchased the equivalent true size (8, in this case). The fit around my foot is perfect and my toes are not jammed against the front of the s...
5/5
Justin D.
3 years ago
amazon.com
Read more
Bogs Arcata Knit Boot
Wide feet, wide calves yes!
Perfect. These are upstate NY warm, with so much room in the width of the toe box. Truly a wide fit calf. Expensive but worth it. Expecting to get many seasons out of these.
5/5
UpstateGrrrl
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more

Style

Astral Loyak Water Shoes
Meets Expectations
Got these near the end of the summer for use while boating and in/near the water. My experience so far: Fit/wearing: The shoes run small. I sent the originals back and then got the next size up. They are designed without a tongue and so are tricky to put on especially at first. Slide your foot all t...
5/5
David N.
1 year ago
amazon.com
Read more
Bogs Arcata Knit Boot
Very warm and well made boots
These are by far the best winter boots ever. Warm, comfortable, well made. Best feature is the pull on “handles”. Make it so easy to get them on and off. The faux fur trim at the top makes them a little bit more fashionable than other heavy duty winter boots.
5/5
Laura B.
2 years ago
amazon.com
Read more