America's Test Kitchen

This tall tool has a sturdy metal mashing plate supported by a long, curved handle made of slip-free plastic. The plethora of small holes on its mashing plate made an ultracreamy, smooth mash, and its handle felt comfortable in hands of all sizes. Its round mashing plate eased effortlessly along the edges of every pan and made quick work of mashing all types of potatoes.

amazon.com

walmart

Wirecutter

Although this masher’s grid plate makes fast work of potato mashing, its stick handle is more awkward to use and provides less leverage than a U-shaped handle.

yotpo

With a grid plate and a comfortable handle, this affordable, simple tool makes quick work of punching through your mash.

This masher cuts into potatoes and other foods faster and more easily than the competition. It’s easy to clean and store, too.

Potato Masher Comparison