Wirecutter

The Blessed Nest Nesting Pillow’s buckwheat hull fill is moldable, so you can change the pillow’s shape and elevation. The organic cotton canvas and terry cloth cover’s colors and prints are more elegant than the typical pastels and cutesy designs of most nursing pillows.

BabyGearLab

We love the Blessed Nest Organic Nesting pillow. This pillow stands out among the competition because its filling is organic buckwheat hulls instead of foam. The buckwheat offers mold-ability that forms to your body and your growing baby. This superior, somewhat customizable support means no awkward hunching or additional pillows to get your baby's head at the right height for feeding. We appreciate the versatility of the Blessed Nest because it also makes a great pregnancy support pillow. This pillow with high-quality materials is sure to last. The GOTS certified outer organic cover is easy to remove for washing, and you'll feel good about your baby's sensitive skin against the material. It does an adequate job absorbing spit-up before it reaches the inner pillow, and you can toss the pillow body in the dryer to help keep things sanitary and free from dust mites. We appreciate the organic material in this pillow, so your baby isn't inhaling potentially toxic fumes 5-8 hours a day. 
The buckwheat makes this pillow heavy. At approximately 5 1/2 lbs, it can feel like a lot when you add the baby's weight on top, especially if you've had a c-section. We recommend using the "football" hold until you heal to help avoid discomfort. This product is also one of the most expensive pillows in this review, but the higher price gives you organic, high-quality materials, so you can justify the cost if your budget allows.   

Best for Most

amazon.com

expert-review

The best nursing pillows you can buy

A favorite of lactation consultants, the My Brest Friend pillow has a firm, flat surface and attaches securely to your body with a buckle, but isn’t as versatile as our other picks.

My Brest Friend Deluxe is a unique, wrap-around pillow. The thick band that wraps around your back provides support to help with any nursing strain, and the wrap-around style keeps the pillow in place so your baby can stay latched. Traditional C-shaped pillows tend to shift and need regular adjusting while nursing. Constant adjustment is not the case with the Brest Friend. Once it is secure, you'll have a firm but soft surface for nursing. We also appreciate the pocket feature. It is a convenient place to keep everything from burp cloths to nipple cream or your phone. When purchasing the Deluxe version of the pillow, you will get a soft and snuggly slipcover, perfect for babies with sensitive skin.
While we love many things about this option, the foam's quality is disappointing, and there is no base cover for added protection. Some users note that the foam can fall apart when removing the slipcover for cleaning. Also, the wrap-around style can be a bit of a pain to put on. Connecting the straps around your body can be challenging while holding a baby, and we suspect some moms will stop using the belt over time. The wrap also utilizes Velcro. While removing it with the silent release straps &#40;whew!&#41;, the Velcro sticking to other materials can be annoying. Overall, we think the pluses outweigh the negatives, making this an option we highly recommend.

target

walmart

bazaarvoice

trustpilot

The Luna Lullaby strikes the best balance of being both soft and supportive, with an ultra-plush cover and a versatile shape that works well for breastfeeding, tummy time, and lounging.

shopify

The Ergobaby Natural Curve is an ergonomically shaped polyurethane foam nursing pillow. It is firm, free from flame retardants, and has a removable cover that is washing machine-friendly. The pillow's thoughtfully designed shape allows for belly-to-belly breastfeeding and keeps the baby's head above the stomach. In addition, the firmness of the material does not lose shape over time. Ergobaby claims that the extra support will help to prevent slouching and back strain while breastfeeding.
This pillow has a more purpose-specific design and may not be as versatile as others. The qualities that make it an excellent nursing pillow prevent it from being useful in other capacities. For example, it is not soft enough to be a comfortable backrest for mom, and it is a bit too structured to use as a support pillow for baby. There is no belt strap on the Natural Curve, and some moms found it challenging to keep the pillow positioned properly without it. However, we found very few flaws with this pillow overall. If you are okay with purchasing a single-function product and would like something to help support good posture, the Ergobaby is a good choice.

The Nook Niche Organic is a u-shaped nursing pillow made mostly of natural materials. The core is 100% organic kapok, which is typically lighter than cotton, compression resistant, hypoallergenic, and has a natural wax coating that inhibits moisture absorption. The cover is a blend of organic cotton, organic eucalyptus, and polyester fibers. This pillow offers more firm support than many other polyfill pillows we tested. The pillow's arms extend back far enough to offer somewhere to rest your elbows, and the outer fabric is grippy enough that the pillow does not slide away from the body. Because the U-shape is pretty narrow, it fits easily into an armchair, and the pillow is flexible enough to bend around most body shapes. We tested the Niche with moms of various sizes, and they all found it to be one of the most comfortable pillows in the group. This pillow excels in baby comfort and provides a resting surface that is long and wide enough to support your child's entire body while nursing. The shape also lends itself well to tummy time, support for babies learning to sit independently, and as a toddler pillow.
Our chief complaint is the durability of the cover. The material is a soft and comforting jersey knit. However, the pebbled texture easily snags and pills when washed. This is something we would not expect from a product of this price. According to Nook, you can reduce the wear on the cover by turning it inside out and zipping it up before washing. The pillow's core is not machine washable, so you will have to be more careful. We feel these are minor flaws in an otherwise fantastic pillow. The Nook Niche is one of our favorite nursing accessories, and if it fits your budget, we think it is a worthwhile purchase.

Nursing Pillow Comparison