Best Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 22" Alternatives

Based on reviews from amazon.com, consumerreports.org, and more.

Things to consider when looking for the best Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker Smoker 22" alternatives

When comparing reviews for products, these are the top things reviewers talk about:

  • Cooking temperature: 16 mentions
  • Durability: 10 mentions
  • Grill design: 10 mentions
  • Price: 6 mentions
  • Size: 5 mentions
  • Fuel efficiency: 2 mentions
  • Warranty: 1 mention
  • Weight: 1 mention
B

Based on 51 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

  • Great for 2 zone cooking
  • Well made and assembles easily
  • Gets real hot for searing
  • Not too small but definitely not big
  • Good value for the price
B

Based on 84 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

Great temperature control
Produces flavorful smoked meats
Versatile with aftermarket products available
Straightforward assembly
Reliable and popular choice for smoking enthusiasts
Not as "set it and forget it" as some users expected
Some users experienced dry meat
Larger model may have difficulty maintaining low temperatures for smaller cuts of meat

Verdict

Overall, the Weber Smokey Mountain Charcoal Smoker receives positive reviews for its ability to maintain temperature and produce flavorful smoked meats. Some users note that it requires more attention than expected, but others appreciate the versatility and aftermarket products available for it. Assembly is generally straightforward, and the 18" model is a good option for those on a budget. Some users mention dry meat or difficulty maintaining low temperatures for smaller cuts of meat on the larger model. Overall, the Weber Smokey Mountain Charcoal Smoker is a reliable and popular choice for smoking enthusiasts.

B

Based on 27 reviews

The Looria Grade (A - F) accounts for multiple factors, including sentiment, helpfulness, and more. Learn about our sources and ranking.

Great build quality
Superior flavor
Versatile for low and slow cooking and high temperature searing
Excellent customer service
Ability to hold temperature for extended periods of time
Not affordable for everyone
Learning curve for heat control
Some reviewers experienced minor damage upon delivery

Verdict

The Big Green Egg Kamado Grill is a high-quality and versatile grill that is well-loved by many. While it is expensive, many reviewers feel that it is worth the investment for the superior flavor and build quality. Some reviewers note that there is a learning curve for heat control, but overall it is easy to assemble and use. The Kamado-style grill is praised for its ability to hold low and slow temperatures for extended periods of time, as well as its ability to sear at high temperatures. Some reviewers mention that there are other Kamado-style grills on the market that are more affordable, but the Big Green Egg is still considered a top-of-the-line option. Overall, the Big Green Egg Kamado Grill is highly recommended for those who are serious about grilling and smoking.