Madewell The Chelsea Rain Boot vs UGG Men’s Butte

I tried a couple different brands this season and these were the nicest and most comfortable. I went with my true size of 8.

It's actually sheepskin material. So if you know anything about Uggs, you know that sheepskin is very, very warm, even sometimes warmer than insulatio...

I usually wear a size 7 but when I got the size 7, it was a huge. I would size down if possible. I returned it for a 6 and it was a better fit. I would have also preferred if the ankle opening was smaller

Only wore them three days total and they stretched out already. Must order a size 0.5x to 1.0x smaller

I wear a size 9, so I ordered a size 9 based on some reviews. They are tight. Need to return for the next size up

5 fit best (though it was a little tight). I had to order a pair because the store didn't have the right color. When the boots arrived, I started wearing them only to realize that they are too big. Also, I had heard about how warm the traditional boot is, but I have not found this style to be very warm (maybe because it is too big or maybe because the lambs wool is only in the upper, not in the waterproof part of the boot?)