Madewell The Chelsea Rain Boot vs UGG Adirondack

I tried a couple different brands this season and these were the nicest and most comfortable. I went with my true size of 8.

I am on my second pair of the Ugg Adirondack tall. They are the best I’ve found for warm toes in Chicago winters.

I usually wear a size 7 but when I got the size 7, it was a huge. I would size down if possible. I returned it for a 6 and it was a better fit. I would have also preferred if the ankle opening was smaller

I return them. I really didn’t want a super long boot just to fit my normal width feet.

I wear a size 9, so I ordered a size 9 based on some reviews. They are tight. Need to return for the next size up

I have been so looking forward to getting these boots in the mail. I have been wanting them for a few years, and was really prepared to love them. I was sadly disappointed though because these boots were so small and narrow that there was no way I could wear them. I am going to try going up a whole size and seeing if they fit then, if they don't, I will have to return them