What is Looria?Sign up

Fitness Tracker

Fitbit Charge 5 vs Withings Steel HR

Fitbit Charge 5

Fitbit Charge 5

287 reviews

View Product Details

Withings Steel HR

Withings Steel HR

63 reviews

View Product Details

Wirecutter · The 4 Best Fitness Trackers 2021

Wirecutter · The Best 3 Smartwatches for Android Phones 2021

Great design and comfortable to wear

Tracks steps, sleep, and other activities

Decent battery life

Affordable price point

Mindfulness sessions available with premium subscription

Great battery life (up to 30 days per charge)

Stylish design

Comfortable to wear

Reliable and accurate heart rate tracking

Accurate sleep tracking

Not the best choice for runners or outdoor activities due to unreliable GPS connectivity

Premium subscription required to access some features

Battery life could be better

Not the best choice for those looking for a comprehensive fitness tracker

Limited fitness tracking capabilities

No GPS tracking

Verdict

The Fitbit Charge 5 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for an all-around device that can track steps, sleep, and other activities. It has a sleek design and is comfortable to wear. The battery life is decent, but could be better. The GPS connectivity is unreliable, so it may not be the best choice for runners or outdoor activities. However, it's still a great option for tracking your daily activity and monitoring your health.

Verdict

The Withings Steel HR is a stylish hybrid smartwatch that offers basic fitness tracking capabilities. It is comfortable to wear and has good battery life, lasting up to 30 days per charge. The heart rate tracking contributes to the Steel HR Sport’s sleep tracking, which is reliable and accurate. However, it may not be the best choice for those looking for a more comprehensive fitness tracker.

Reviews by Topic

Our analysis shows how reviewers feel about different topics. Please note these are not full reviews.

Connectivity

Good for most common uses but GPS connection is lacking.

Edit: I ended up sending the device back because the GPS is so unreliable. Maybe there's another FItBit model with better GPS connectivity, but this particular one isn't going to work for me.

Hi folks, do any of you have this Steel HR? If so, do you know if you have to have your phone with you for the GPS to work? It seems like a really nice watch but, from what I've read, it only works with a phone, ie for GPS tracking. Anyone know about this? Thanks,

Neutral

reddit.com/r/smartwatch

Fit

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 review: Why you're MISSING OUT if you're not wearing this smart fitness tracker

Fitbit has basically become a household name in the tracker health monitor field, but the company hasn't been resting on its laurels. They continue to...

Positive

Withings Steel HR Sport Review

It's a worthwhile purchase if you like the style, but know that its smart features come secondary to its design.

Positive

Activity Tracking

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 Review - still worth it in 2022?

The while for its price, the Fitbit Charge 5 offers a lot. It won't be the perfect fit for everyone. With limited workout tracking features and a less...

Positive

youtube

Maybe This WASN'T The Best Choice - My First Smartwatch

So that's pretty awesome and the only physical interaction you have is the side button to see your time, your heart, break, distance and battery life ...

Positive

Comfortability

Fitbit charge 5 or garmin vivo 4 or other (Polar)? Focus on general wellness (F26)

I can comment on the Charge 5 comfort - it's amazing, I have it on 24/7 and don't even know it's there.

Positive

reddit.com/r/fitbit

I currently have an Apple Watch but I’m going to be wearing my analog watch again - I prefer the aesthetics and don’t need all the features and distractions of a smartwatch.

Positive

reddit.com/r/fitbit

Comfort

Back to Fitbit… Kind of….

The Fitbit Charge 5 is better in every way except form/fit. As long as you can stand something on your wrist, I highly advise against the Oura ring.

Negative

reddit.com/r/fitbit

I love it, but it has flaws.

Comfort: I find the watch comfortable to wear throughout the day; however, I've found myself waking up at night due to the discomfort of the watch. Idk if it's because I'm pregnant and my arm is swelling at night, but this is disappointing bc the main reason I bought this watch was to track my sleep (or lack thereof). Also, once I wake up at like 330am and go back to sleep and wake up like 3 or 4 more times before 730, it doesn't track the sleep bc you have to be asleep for like 3 hrs straight before it tracks again. Step accuracy: seems accurate

Notifications

Brighter screen, but for me an overall downgrade.

So, when I walked the neighborhood loop to my house, it really is nice when my Charge 4 let me know that I also did the equivalent of about 10 flights of stairs with each loop. Without the altimeter, that information cannot be shown.

Beautiful concept, disappointing implementation...

Third, literally the ONLY messages you get notifications for are SMS messages, and even then, only if you are using the stock text-messaging app. No WhatsApp, no Signal, no Facebook Messenger, no Google Hangouts, nothing. Effectively, this watch is utterly useless at the single most important function a smartwatch can provide! 3) The smart wakeup feature depends upon the watch’s alarm. They aren’t joking about the “Alarm” part, either

Price

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 In-Depth Review: 9 New Things to Know

And today we've got a complete review of the new FitBit Charge 5, as well as nine new things to know about this unit. Now, I've been using it for a wh...

Neutral

A decent enough fitness tracker for the casual crowd

I've noticed more believable data the more nights I've worn it (even the filled-in data). Conclusion: Overall I do not regret the purchase, BUT it is a little pricey. I would've felt more comfortable with the price being closer to $125. I believe this could be a watch for people who aren't really interested in fast and accurate data, but more so for the casual crowd of folks who need to see minimal data during their workouts and runs

Battery Life

Is fitbit dodgy?

Then there's the disgusting battery life which seems to be caused by bad software. 7+ days battery life advertised on the box but it barely gets 24 hours with even with features turned off.

Negative

reddit.com/r/fitbit

Withings Steel HR review: Your everyday watch with heart rate

I could see my wife was calling. I couldn't read what her previous text was. Most watch features don't need the second screen. Sarah Tew/CNETThe best part of Steel HR might be battery life

Neutral

Durability

Poor out of box experience, Spo2 issues

One downside is the apparent need to sign up for an expensive membership, but I figured I'd give it a year and let the Fitbit ecosystem prove its value. The trouble started almost immediately when I unboxed the device and went through the initial setup. Total PTSD, from previous attempts to use Fitbit hardware & software. Here, the device kept failing to perform the initial software update

Are smart watches for Android worth it?

I have a Withings Steel HR hybrid watch. Does everything I need, had good battery life and just works. Not very flashy, but I find it very functional.

Positive

reddit.com/r/GooglePixel

Design

youtube

Fitbit Charge 5 review

In a world filled with smartwatches, fitness trackers feel kind of liberating. They're smaller, they generally have better battery life, and they're e...

Positive

Here’s a story spanning three gadgets, two brands, and one pretty great fitness app

Their subtle gamification and classy design turned me from a fitness app hater into someone who tracks his weight, body composition, steps, and sleep on a daily basis and is actively enjoying the whole thing.

Positive

QUICK QUESTION!

Got an opinion on a product you've used?
If so, we want to hear from you! Write an authentic longevity review about the product and share your experience with our community. You'll have the chance to win a $100 gift card.

You might also like

More Alternatives

Fitbit Inspire 2

Fitbit Inspire 2

Garmin Forerunner 35

Garmin Forerunner 35

Fitbit Charge 4

Fitbit Charge 4

Withings Steel HR

Withings Steel HR

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 3

Fitbit Charge 5

Fitbit Charge 5

More Alternatives